Hi all, what is the current state of ldap-proxy-plugin, is it developing or freezed? The GitHub repo has very low activity, issues and pull requests are staying without answers by maintainers for years…
We very much recommend not to use the LDAP proxy.
- The LDAProtocol is NO authentication protocol.
- 3rd party applications can use LDAP in different ways to authenticate users. This means, some applications might work with the LDAP proxy - others do not.
- The LDAProtocol provides a poor user experience, due to the nature of LDAP. I.e. the 3rd party application will say “username”, “password” and you do not have the possibility to tell the user what to do. I.e. The user needs to know, that he needs to enter PIN+OTP.
- Due to the nature of LDAP only limited and old tokentypes can be supported. I.e. OTP. Even Challenge/Response is not possible. It will never be possible to support PUSH-Token in a sensible way or Webauthn/Passkeys at all.
We recommend to use more modern authentication protocols like SAML or OpenID connect, which support all available authentication mechanisms.
Is it possible to get rid of your old and dusty 3rd party applications?
Or tell them to move…?
(I am using “3rd party applications” for applications that you are currently using and that are not developed, controlled or influenced by the privacyIDEA team)
Thanks! Unfortunately LDAP is still needed. The application is not very old, but there is no other integration with 2FA
The application is needed LDAP (HashiCorp VAULT), but the PrivacyIDEA in my case is used not only for authentication but also for authorisation, the groups for corresponding permissions are taken from LDAP…
I think there might be other ways
Unfortunately, I didn’t find the way ![]()
Anyway my question is more about the developing status of the project: I have made several Pull Requests at GitHub with enhancements of functionality of LDAP-proxy more then a year ago, but there are no answers there… If it should be considered as legacy/deprecated, then I have no more questions, but I didn’t found any information of EOL date…